6 Plushiest Feather Mattress Toppers for Your Best Sleeping Experience

Reviewed by
Last updatedLast updated: April 08, 2022
Talk About Sleep is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here

Studies estimate that the average person will spend at least one-third of their lives sleeping. That equates to roughly 229,961 hours in total. With this in mind, shouldn’t finding the right bedding accessories be considered an important task?

Today we’ll be looking at six of the best feather mattress toppers and giving you a breakdown of their specifications. One of the features we considered in these toppers is the size since mattress toppers are not one size fits all products. Considering the fill and thickness of the topper is also important because that determines whether you’ll get the right comfort and support. Aside from the product reviews, we’ll also be attaching a handy buying guide which will give you a more detailed summary of the features you need to take into account. There will also be a section for the pros and cons of choosing feather mattress toppers. All this information should make finding the best feather mattress topper a lot simpler.

Top 6 Feather Mattress Toppers Review 2022

  • Filling: white down and goose feather
  • Cover: cotton
  • Thickness: 2 inches
  • Sizes available: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Cal King

More features: 550 fill power; multi-layer construction; 300-thread-count cover; skirt fits up to 20-inch deep mattress; Responsible Down Standard certified

The Allied Essentials Luxe offers you hotel-style comfort. Made with ultra-soft white down and goose feather, this topper offers exceptional comfort. The multi-layer, turtle top construction features a dual compartment that adds to the softness and fluffiness. The bottom layer is made of goose feather, and the top – of goose down. This offers extra support on the bottom, adding to your comfort.

Certified by the Responsible Down Standard, this mattress topper features a natural hypoallergenic characteristic, ensuring that your allergies won’t act up when you’re sleeping on this at night.

The topper also features a framed box-quilted top layer and a two-inch-thick baffled box-quilted bottom packed with goose feathers. This gives you that hotel-style comfort this topper is known for! Available sizes include twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, and Cal king so you’re guaranteed to find the right size for any bed in your home!

What are our favorite features? We like that this topper skirt fits 20 inches deep mattresses. There are also many sizes to choose from. The topper is very soft, and overall quality is excellent.

What could be better? The topper tends to be slightly too small for the bed, irrespective of what size you’re buying. It generally leaves about two inches on either side.

  • Filling: feather and down
  • Cover: cotton
  • Thickness: 2 inches
  • Sizes available: Twin, Full, Queen, King, Cal King

More features: 230-thread-count cotton cover; two-layer construction; ADFC and RDS certified

Serta is known for offering comfortable bedding products. This feather and down topper is the ideal solution to plump up a mattress that’s getting a little worn. Made from 100% cotton, the cover’s thread count is 233, meaning it won’t rip that easily.

The inside is filled with Hypoallergenic Down fiber top and a Small Feather Base which goes a long way to ensuring a comfortable night’s rest. A stringent cleaning process ensures that foreign particles, dirt, and allergens have been removed from the down and feathers. This cleaning process makes the topper fresher and fluffier and ensures it has the highest levels of purity. To add to that, Serta products are also certified by the American Down and Feather Council as well as the Responsible Down Standard.

Standard size ranges of twin, full, queen, king, and the additional Cal king will ensure you find the right size to fit your mattress perfectly.

What we liked

The multiple washes and rinse cycles this product has gone through give us peace of mind that the topper lives up to its promise of being hypoallergenic.

What could be better

This mattress topper isn’t as fluffy as promised. It won’t provide the cushioning that you’d expect from a Serta product.

  • Filling: Resilia feathers
  • Cover: cotton
  • Thickness: 3 inches
  • Sizes available: Twin, Queen

More features: 230-thread-count cover; 5-year limited warranty and 30-night trial

This topper model is imported from Europe and offers an extra layer of soft quilting. This extra quilting, together with the springy Resilia feathers, provides you with the support your shoulders and hips need for a peaceful night’s rest. With its three-inch thickness, this topper is the ultimate way to refresh an older or flat mattress.

An allergen-free warranty ensures that the down used is free from allergens and dirt particles. The feathers stay in place thanks to the true baffle box design of the topper.

Resilia feathers have been hyper cleaned and a 100% cotton barrier weave ensures the feathers don’t leak out, giving you peace of mind about the quality of the product you’ve bought.

The manufacturer is so confident in its product that it offers a 30-night comfort guarantee on the topper. Simply use the product for 30 nights to establish if it offers you the comfort levels you need. If not, simply return it for a full refund. In addition to that, there’s also a 5-year limited warranty from the manufacturer for the peace of mind.

Unfortunately, this topper is only available in twin and queen sizes.

What we liked

The product is hypoallergenic, so there’s no chance of getting hay fever from the downs or feathers used.

What could be better

It’s a bit uncomfortable when it comes to side sleeping.


Bluestone Down & Duck Feather 4" Gusset TopperBest Topper for Side Sleepers

  • Filling: duck feathers, down feathers
  • Cover: cotton
  • Thickness: 4 inches
  • Sizes available: Twin, Full, Queen, King

More features: 233-thread-count cover

The Bluestone Down topper is filled with 95% duck and 5% down feathers and covered in 100% cotton. With its four-inch thickness, it’s thicker than most other toppers in this category. This makes it even softer to lie on.

It also sports a baffle box construction. This not only maximizes the toppers’ fluffiness but also keeps the filling from falling out. It also keeps the down and feathers evenly distributed to avoid uncomfortable scrunching in the corner or the center.

What we liked

The baffle box construction is a great feature. It ensures the down and feather filling doesn’t scrunch to one side, which will make the center uncomfortable.

What could be better

We think this topper should have some ties to secure it to the bed as it moves around.


puredown Premium Natural White Goose Overfilled Bed TopperBest Feather and Alternative Combo

  • Filling: white goose feather; polyester
  • Cover: cotton
  • Thickness: 3 inches
  • Sizes available: Twin, Full, Queen, King

More features: two-layer construction; Responsible Down Standard and OXIPOWER certified

This high-quality topper offers you a level of comfort that won’t disrupt your sleep. Made from 100% cotton, the top layer is filled with 75% natural white goose down, while the bottom is filled with feather. This provides just the right balance of down and feather to provide exceptional comfort. There’s no need to worry about the filling shifting thanks to the baffle box construction and double-needle stitching.

An elastic fiber allows for an easy set-up, so you won’t struggle to put it on the bed. Another plus point here is the topper has been certified by OXIPOWER which means it’s been cleaned and disinfected. The down and feather combo is lightweight and odorless ensuring there won’t be any discomfort during your sleep. The topper has a thickness of 3 inches, and the available sizes are twin, full, queen and king, ensuring you’ll find the right fit for your bed. Users consider this topper the best feather mattress topper for side sleepers.

What we liked

The baffle box construction is a handy feature. It prevents the down from shifting and getting scrunched up in the bottom.

What could be better

There’s a chemical smell straight out of the packaging that requires about four washes to clear. This is not ideal if the intent is to buy it and use it on the same day.


DOWNCOOL Feather Bed Mattress TopperMost Affordable Topper

  • Filling: down feather
  • Cover: cotton
  • Thickness: 2 inches
  • Sizes available: Twin, Full, Queen, King, Cal King

More features: machine washable

This high-quality mattress topper has a soft flannelette design. It’s filled with an excellent quality feather and down combination. The cotton fabric is soft and breathable ensuring you’ll have a restful night’s sleep.

The baffle box stitching ensures that the down and feathers won’t scrunch at the bottom or in the corners. It’s also fluffy and thick, adding to your comfort.

With its double design, every effort has been made to ensure feathers don’t leak through. This topper is also machine washable, making it easy to keep clean and fresh.

Downcool has toppers available in twin, full, queen, king, and Cal king, ensuring that you’ll definitely find the right size for your bed.

What we liked

We like that this topper is machine washable.

What could be better

It’s great that you can machine wash it. However, drying it in the drier will cause it to shrink. This causes a concern for people living where there’s no access to washing lines.

Things to Consider

Buying a feather mattress topper is not as simple as you might think. There are several factors that ultimately affect your comfort. In our handy buyer’s guide, we’ll be looking at some of the features to consider before choosing a feather mattress topper. We’ll also be looking at some pros and cons of using a feather mattress topper and how that affects

 your comfort levels.

Feather mattress toppers: pros and cons

As with every other product you might purchase, a feather mattress topper has its pros and cons. Let’s have a look at a few of these:


  • Increased comfort
  • Lightweight
  • Ease back pain
  • Less heat retention
  • Easy movement
  • Inexpensive


  • Can lose fluffiness
  • Can be uncomfortable for side sleepers

Features to consider before you buy a feather mattress topper

6 Plushiest Feather Mattress Toppers for Your Best Sleeping Experience

When you’ve decided to purchase a feather top mattress, there are several features to take into consideration before making your final decision. It’s important to read through this section and take all these factors into consideration. This will ensure you purchase the right type of feather mattress topper for your bed size and your personal comfort.


When it comes to the filling of your mattress topper, feather and down isn’t the only option available. To pick the right option for your own bed, take into consideration how hot the topper will be and how much comfort you’re likely to get from it.

Common options include the following:

  • Feather: These are soft mattress toppers, but they don’t always provide the support needed. They can often be hot as well. They can be made from down and feathers from either goose or duck.
  • Polyester blend: Fiberfill, or polyester blend, is the cheapest of mattress toppers. These toppers also tend to get very hot. This could make sleeping uncomfortable.
  • Ploy Foam and Latex: These types of toppers are only a good idea if your mattress is firm and already provides enough body support. These are also a great choice if your budget is limited.
  • Memory Foam: A big advantage of the memory foam topper is you get the comfort of a memory foam mattress without having to pay for an actual mattress. Memory foam is also a great choice for body support.

Our reviews cover two types of the feather and down fillings. The Bluestone Down & Duck Feather Topper is made of a combination of duck down and feathers. Some toppers are made from white goose feathers and down. Examples of this on our review list include the puredown topper and the Allied Essentials Luxe Featherbed topper.


Mattress topper covers should be made from 100% cotton to ensure that the feathers don’t poke through the material. A strong cover also keeps the filling from falling out. The Serta 2-inch topper on our review list has a 300 thread count, making it very durable.

A feature to look out for is the baffle box feature. This means that the topper is divided into different squares and sewn across each square. This creates different sewn sections, and the point of this is to keep the filling from moving around or scrunching at the bottom or middle. This will ensure your topper is soft all over. An example of this is the puredown feather topper.


Ideally the thickness you’re looking for in a mattress topper should be anything between 2 and 3 inches. A rule of thumb here is that if you require a thicker topper to be comfortable, it’s a sign that your mattress needs replacing.

On our review list, we have the puredown topper at 3 inches. The Bluestone Down & Duck Feather Topper is 4 inches thick, making this choice more comfortable than the average product.

Available sizes

Don’t assume that “one size fits all” when it comes to mattress toppers. Ensure that the size of the topper will cover the size of your mattress. A point to be aware of here is that some toppers like the Allied Essentials Luxe mattress topper tend to be slightly smaller than the bed. It might be a good idea to take actual measurements to ensure that your sizes match up.

Some toppers are also not available in all sizes. The Pacific Coast Feather Luxe topper is only available in twin and queen. Others like the Serta 2-Inch feather topper are available in all sizes, making it a sure thing that you’ll find the right size.


6 Plushiest Feather Mattress Toppers for Your Best Sleeping Experience

Toppers could cost up to an estimated 50% of the cost it would be to replace your mattress. Ensure that your mattress is still within its lifespan. This will ensure that you don’t spend money on a mattress topper which won’t solve the comfort problem you’re experiencing.


In general, down has a reputation for being of better quality than feathers. This is due to it being softer, fluffier, and it lacks quills. When it comes to the type of down, the preferred choice is goose down. Geese usually produce bigger down clusters which make the topper fluffier. Feather mattress toppers are effective at softening a firm mattress and usually cost less. A disadvantage of the feather choice is that they might poke through the cover which could cause discomfort.

Usually back and spine sleepers need a lot more support to ensure their spines remain well aligned. A topper used for stomach sleepers should provide more firmness to prevent shoulders and hips from sinking too far down and causing back strain. Stomach sleepers who weigh anything between 130 and 230 pounds tend to favor a medium to medium-firm type which falls between 5 and 6 on the firmness scale.

Feather toppers are usually made from the plumage of ducks or geese. Some coarser, exterior feathers are also used to fill these types of toppers. Down is a term used to describe the combination of outer feathers and softer, underside plumage. Down is much lighter than feathers and is often used in duvets and toppers.

Our Verdict

We hope that our reviews on feather mattress toppers have given you some clarity on the choices available. If you’re still not entirely decided on your favorite, let’s recap our top three.

The Allied Essentials Luxe mattress topper is our editor’s choice, and we’ve rated it at 9.8. This topper impressed us because it offers hotel-style comfort with its down and feather combo. This is convenient because it almost guarantees you a restful night’s sleep.

Our second favorite is the Serta 2-Inch featherbed which is our best value choice because of its hypoallergenic feature and rates 9.7.

Lastly, we have the Pacific Coast Feather Luxe topper, our best all feather toppers. We rated it 9.5 because of its extra quilting and allergen-free warranty.

We trust that our product review has provided you with the necessary information to decide on your favorite. Choosing the best feather mattress topper is all about comfort. With the information in our buyers’ guide this should be much easier now!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.