Mattress Topper or New Mattress: What to Choose?

This article, with its precise analysis and pros and cons, will help you to choose between buying a new mattress or just adding a topper to the one you already have.
Romeo Vitelli
Romeo Vitelli
Expert Writer
Received his doctorate in Psychology in 1987, spent fifteen years as a staff psychologist in Millbrook Correctional Centre. In 2003 went into full-time private practice. read more
Reviewed By
Medical Advisory Team
Medical Advisory Team
Includes well-known professionals, who together provide decades of sleep medicine experience that enables Talk About Sleep to fulfill its mission of creating access to high- read more
Last updated: September 04, 2023
TalkAboutSleep is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here

Comfort is key in the bedroom, and a good mattress is among the aspects that make this a reality—until recently, buying a new one was the only solution available. Currently, manufacturers in this industry bring an array of products to the market that could be the solution you are looking for. Mattress toppers come at a lower price than getting a new one. The Linen Spa 3 Inch Swirl memory foam topper is among the finest of the many products on the market. Reviews from a decent chunk of previous buyers indicate a durable model with ventilated gel swirl design.

Most people face one tough choice when they visit virtual and brick-and-mortar stores: whether to go for a mattress topper or a new mattress. Evaluating the condition of the unit you have will determine the best alternative for you. Below we discuss the pros and cons of each.

What about a new mattress?

Mattress Topper or New Mattress: What to Choose?

The choice to get a new mattress is dependent on some factors. The financial implication of buying a new unit is one of your top concerns. Mattresses do not come cheap, but this does not mean that you will not find one within your budget range. Some of the best memory foam mattress toppers cost more than getting a new one. Durability and comfort are the other factors that you should bear in mind. These two will dictate the pricing of the units that will fit your preference.

Buy mattresses from reputable manufacturers and retailers. Here are some of the pros and cons of buying a new mattress.


  • Allergy protection – over time, mattresses collect dust and other allergens that can be detrimental to your health. Buying a new unit helps eliminate this problem, among others. Clean your bed frame before placing the mattress you buy to prevent the transfer of allergens, dust, and particles.
  • Better health – a new mattress ensures that your spine aligns and your body receives the support that it needs. This helps you relax and achieve normal functioning by the time you wake up. Improved blood supply and alleviation from pains and aches are among the benefits you reap when you buy a new mattress.


  • Cost – buying a new mattress will cost you a fortune. If you have had your unit for less than seven years and the damage is not severe, consider getting a topper Trusted Source The mattress landfill crisis: how the race to bring us better beds led to a recycling nightmare | Waste | The Guardian As the sleep economy grows, companies vie to sell us new mattresses, offering 100-day returns. This has helped create an impossible waste mountain – and a wild west of rogue recycler .

What about a mattress topper?

Mattress Topper or New Mattress: What to Choose?

Mattress toppers are an inexpensive solution that you can opt for when looking for a quick fix. Although most information on the internet points towards this being a cheap option, this is not always the case. The various alternatives available have pros and cons that you ought to evaluate before deciding. Manufacturers use different cutting-edge technologies to ensure good performance and comfort for the users. According to many reviews, the ViscoSoft 3 Inch Memory Foam Mattress Topper Queen is among products that feature the latest tech in the market. It is an affordable option with a 60-day money-back guarantee. Some of the advantages and disadvantages of opting for a mattress topper include.


  • Extends mattress life – getting a new mattress will cost you an arm and a leg if you are interested in top-tier products. Getting a topper costs less, and it helps solve the issue for an extended period. Buy a compatible unit with your mattress and the problem you need to solve for effective outcomes.
  • Affordable – cost is one factor that you need to consider before you settle on a solution. Mattress toppers are an inexpensive option that you can fall back on to save money. You can achieve the same results as buying a new mattress if you choose to purchase a topper. Additionally, the various brands in the market are durable units availing the necessary comfort for a long time.


  • Firmness – Most of the brands you will find in the market are firm, which may be uncomfortable for some people. When shopping, go for units with features that are ideal for you. For instance, you can find excellent mattress toppers for side sleepers if you are one. The firmness may be a discomfort the first few days before you enjoy your topper.

Final thoughts

The need to solve the issue you have regarding your mattress may seem urgent but you do not have to rush in making a decision. If you can salvage the situation a topper can solve the problem. However, if your mattress has severe wear and tear getting a new one will be a suitable solution. When shopping for toppers reviews all the fundamental features to ensure that you get a good deal.

Luckily, manufacturers bring a wide variety to consumers including feather mattress toppers with additional elements for extra comfort. The reviews from experts and testimonials from other users will help you make a well-versed choice whether you are looking to buy a new mattress or a topper. The solution you opt for should be within your budget to ground your expenditure avoiding unnecessary spending.


The mattress landfill crisis: how the race to bring us better beds led to a recycling nightmare | Waste | The Guardian
As the sleep economy grows, companies vie to sell us new mattresses, offering 100-day returns. This has helped create an impossible waste mountain – and a wild west of rogue recycler
Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *