Marcus is an orthopedic spine surgeon who knows for sure how to ease ache in your back, neck, and shoulders, and prevent meeting him in person.
Last updated: August 16, 2021
Talk About Sleep is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here
Do you find yourself tossing and turning, casting your pillow to the side when it fails to give you comfort in the middle of the night? Have you cursed out loud the makers of your pillow for “stealing your money” when their labels promised you a decent slumber with their product, but you couldn’t find one? Then keep reading because we know how that feels.
If you want to finally own the pillow that’s filled with the “right stuff” and gives you what you need to confidently rest your head, close your eyes, and sleep properly, then you’ve come to the best place.
Xtreme Comforts shredded foam stuffing is comfortably soft and can be used for most of your home stuffing needs. This durable foam material never fails to instill relaxation and was a pleasure to use for our review team.
The most recent addition to the Xtreme Comforts lineup contains stuffing designed with memory foam that’s easy to install and begins expanding as soon as you fill it into your desired container. The base package comes in a 5lb variation that is an adequate amount of stuffing for a variety of household needs. Xtreme Comforts has you covered with bigger packages coming in 10lb and 20lb packages, ensuring that you can place comfort throughout every aspect of your life. Compared to other similar models, the Healthy Shredded Memory Foam Pillow can sustain lots of use, consistent comfort and is CertiPUR-US Certified. If you’re looking for high quality and the overall best filling for comfort pillows attainable, then look no further.
What makes it stand out?
We loved Xtreme Comfort Safe and Healthy Shredded Memory Foam Pillow Stuffing for its easy installation, overall comfort, multipurpose design, consistent comfort levels, different amount variations, and reasonable price point. Whether stuffing your bed pillows, bean bags, throw pillows, couch cushions, or anything that you need to be comfortable and easy to use, Xtreme Comforts has your back with the best stuffing for pillows available.
Which disadvantages must you keep in mind?
The price isn't too steep, but if you'd like to spend a little less, then there are other options for you.
The Original Poly-Fil Premium Box contains some of the best pillow filling for comfort on the market.
For the last few years, Fairfield has nearly perfected its formula and provided a 100% polyester material that is a great filling for throw pillows. The original model package comes in a 20lb box and is more than enough for your pillow needs. Its new and improved design renders every casing it fills with a soft and comfortable cushion. Stuffing stuffed animals or craft pillows has never been so easy or simple.
What are our favorite features?
We were blown away by the 100% recycled polyester material, minimalist packaging design, choices of 20lb or 40lbs, softness of the filling, and zero amount of added chemicals during manufacturing. Our team found the simple installation one of the best components of this stuffing and put Fairfield near the top where it belongs.
What could be better?
One drawback we found was the price tag. With so many other affordable options on the market, the base price seemed a little out of the budget for someone looking to save some money and get the best filling for comfort pillows. The lack of certification also detracted from the overall amazing experience we found during testing this product.
Goose down Feather Stuffing and Fill is a lush and hypoallergenic treat for people looking to provide unending softness and delight when using their pillows.
The 5lb base package offers all-natural European geese feathers with a 10%/90% ratio of down/feathers in a spacious package. Their formula provides hypoallergenic results and can help to fill pillows, restore clothing, puff up comforters, and make any type of item have that amazing down feeling. If you need the soft comfort of down in bulk, then you’re in luck because there are also 10lb and 20lb packages that provide more-than-enough comfort for anything you can think of.
Why did it make our list?
Goose Down Feather Stuffing and Fill is a winner due to its hypoallergenic design, certified RDS manufacturing process, multipurpose use, extra soft consistency, and reasonable price. We found this product to be one of the best natural fillings for pillows you can get.
What is not ideal about it?
The biggest downside for this item is that it isn't for anyone who wants a firmer material. The downmix is super plush and wouldn’t support those who need a more solid feel for their filling needs.
COYMOS has created a truly flexible and supportive material that stands toe to toe with the best fillings for pillows on the market. The bounce-back quality of this mattress-grade foam is apparent as it shined through every element of our testing.
Its latest innovative product brings COYMOS ahead of a lot of the competition with 10lbs of shredded memory foam for crafting several pillows, bean bags, small beds, and more. With special quality gel particles, the memory foam here provides support with human beings in mind as the design is contoured for comfort. Compared to other leading brands, COYMOS Shredded Memory foam provides excellent levels of comfort in sleeping areas and lounging places.
What are its best features?
The standout features that made this some of the best filling for sleeping and the best filling for couch pillows are its innovative gel particle design, 0% irritants in its manufacturing and packing process, cost efficiency, breathability, and snap-back memory foam features.
What could be improved?
We think that COYMOS could have created a material that is more multipurpose and less pigeonholed for just cushions, pillows, and places of rest. Also, a lack of certification allows competitors to have an advantage while in the market for this type of product.
Coop Home Goods Memory Foam and Polyfill is a great and affordably priced polyester memory foam that provides quality, consistent comfort level, and won’t break the bank.
Recently, Coop Home Goods introduced a new shredded gel-infused memory foam bringing a bounce-back material to their stellar pillow stuffing options that have reinforced their legitimacy as a top contender. The original Loft product offered by Coop Home Goods had a crosscut memory phone and microfiber blend, but the newly added shredded gel memory foam in the Eden model has changed the game. Our comparisons with other brands have rendered this certified offering the best filling for comfort pillows and are nearly unbeatable for price and ease of use.
What makes it special?
This pillow stuffing was great for its medium-density comfort level, cutting-edge gel technology, unbeatable price, and GREENGAURD Gold and CertiPur-US Certifications.
What cons did we find?
We think that a wider variety of comfort levels would give this pillow filling a bigger advantage in the competition, but besides that Coop Home Goods Memory Foam and Poly Fill is one of the best.
Mountain Mist Fiberloft Polyester Stuffing is the affordable and overall best-valued pillow filling we have reviewed. It’s ideal for quick fixes, arts and crafts, small clothing modifications, and other modest jobs.
Mountain Mist Fiberloft Polyester stuffing comes in a single variation of 3-pound packaging, or people can order multiple bags at a discounted cost. The 100% polyester fill is soft and comfortable for a plethora of uses. In the scope of other brands, we found Fiberloft to be the budget-friendly yet consistent option for individuals looking for a quick and reliable staffing solution.
What are our favorite features?
We loved the vacuum-sealed packaging, the local US manufacturing process, the great quality fiber, the polyester design, and the amazing price point.
What could be better?
We would have liked to see certification for Fiberloft as well as a larger packaged amount for people with large projects in mind. This product is not recommended for those who need lots of filling because of the maximum 3-pound bag.
LOKUNN Store offers a minimalist package containing excellent and durable polyester pillow fill that lasts through the endless and extreme conditions of rough fluffing and washer/dryer cycles. This affordable pillow stuffing is great for pillows, cushions, and crafts.
Fiberfill is an ideal material that is suitable for every night pillows and stuffed animals offered in a simplistic package that is extremely user-friendly and super easy to use. Different size packages are available, which allows this product to fill a variety of stuffing or filling needs. When we compared this product to similar brands, Fiberfill came out ahead in price, ease-of-use, softness, and should go neck and neck with many brands in the market space.
What are our favorite features?
We loved the elegant packaging design, softness, multipurpose design angle, cost-efficient price, reliability, easy-to-clean material, and much more.
What could be better?
We do wish it would come in a bulk package for users who need more. Also, the lack of certification makes other options stand out when in the market for pillow stuffing.
Things to Consider
While in the market for quality pillow stuffing to provide the comfort, pressure, material, and design that gives you confidence when you go to sleep or sit on your couch, it’s good to know your options. We’ve broken down an extensive and detailed buying guide to steer you down the path towards a pillow-filling purchase you can be proud of.
How to Choose the Filling?
Choosing a filling for pillows has a lot to do with your preferences and the specific needs of your stuffing. Different determining factors and features can navigate you through the pillow-filling marketplace in many different directions. Whether looking for the best filling for outdoor pillows or the best filling for floor pillows, our extensive buying guide can pinpoint the right buy.
Understanding the features that stand out to you as the go-to reasons why a pillow filling may be the right choice is important. Here are some great factors we have laid out that may be important for you:
If you’re looking for natural filling for pillows that provide hypoallergenic and reputably sourced material, then options like the Goose Down Feather Stuffing and Fill can give you what you desire.
Different material offers varying experiences in comfort and pressure. One choice can make or break the experience of pillow filling for floor pillows, throw pillows, outdoor pillows, and more.
Memory foam filling mixed with different gels and quality materials like the Coop Home Goods Memory Foam stuffing introduces cutting-edge technologies infused in one package.
All-natural filling like the Goose Down Feather Stuffing and Fill gives you the comfort of nature for your decorative pillows and is an amazing option for those in the market for pillows for allergies.
Polyester is another widely used, durable, and go-to stuffing for comfort pillows, throw pillows, couch pillows, and even arts and crafts.
The weight of stuffing for pillows is a considerable option depending on what your pillow will be used for. Lightweight options like Mountain Mist Fiberloft can have your decorative pillows extra fluffy, soft, and mobile. However, if you need filling for couch cushions or outdoor pillows, then a heavier choice like COYMOS Shredded Memory Foam Filling can get the job done.
Very few factors indicate a well-tested and industry-leading product, as well as certification, can. Perhaps you want to know that your natural and hypoallergenic down filling for your throw pillows or jacket is officially RDS approved, like Goose Down Feather Stuffing and Fill.
This quality assurance mark can nearly guarantee that the filling you are paying for has passed industry standards and is suitable for all who buy.
Firmness and density
The final feel of filling for pillows and other items can make a huge difference when starting out in choosing what stuff to get.
A softer and lighter filling for things like throw pillows, stuffed animals, and/or arts and crafts can have you lean towards products like LOKUNN’s Stores’ Polyester Fiberfill providing easy-to-move creations.
More dense and firm options like the COYMOS Shredded Memory Foam Filling can give that near-mattress level density that you can fall asleep on and is a great material for couch pillows.
The filling for pillows that’s right for you is truly determined by the intention behind its purchase. Different materials and components work best for varying reasons like:
Filling up your couch pillows, dog beds, or bean chairs
Stuffing your outdoor pillows, throw pillows, or bed pillows
Making sure your feather coats are puffy enough
Getting the softest and most malleable filling for arts and crafts
Making sure you know exactly what you need your filling for can help you narrow down your options for a more efficient purchase.
If you are prone to allergies from different fabrics and materials, then certain types of filling for pillows are better suited for you than others. All-natural stuffing like Goose Down Feather Stuffing and Fill or other naturally RDS certified brands of down materials could help someone avoid stuffing that may induce allergic reactions. A hypoallergenic filling is labeled on all packages, so make sure to read the item description before you buy.
One regular 20″ by 26″ standard sleeping pillow requires around 2lbs of material to fully stuff it efficiently for use. Depending on your pillow needs, bigger casings require larger amounts of filling for pillows. Also, the density and firmness of the stuffing you use may modify the amount that you need.
Although products like Fairfield’s The Original Poly Fill Premium Box have easy instructions for unpacking its filling, all stuffing for pillows of any type requires some tools to complete the job. You will need a rotary cutter, a ruler, piping cord, small scissors, #5 zipper foot/feet, a thimble, thread, hand sewing needles, curved needles, button kit covers, and a stuffing tool. Most of these items can be bought at an arts and crafts store or online.