Zinus vs LUCID: Which Is Better for You?

Can't decide between Zinus and LUCID? We compared them for you.
Last updated: Oct 27, 2019
0 comments
vs
Can't decide between Zinus and LUCID? We compared them for you.
62 Hours of Research
10 Experts Interviewed
150 Reviews Analyzed

Zinus vs LUCID: which mattress to pick from those two options and why? Given the fact that you spend at least a quarter of your life sleeping, these are some essential questions that need answering. LUCID claims this 10-inch mattress as their best-selling option yet and the Zinus is also not far behind in terms of sales. As such you can tell that the two mattresses are quite popular. If you go through the features listed for both of these options, you start to understand why they are favored. They are versatile options that people from almost all walks of life can use to relax after the day’s activities. Also, their prices are different, which may account for some of the difference in sales. You will note that both options are made from memory foam with the Zinus being thicker by about two inches. As such, you may draw the conclusion that it is the same mattress with the only difference being branding and size. However, just because they use foam as part of their construction does not mean that they are the same. If you’ve slept on different types of foam mattresses before you would know the experience is different and that composition is just as crucial in influencing the quality of sleep.

Consequently comparing LUCID vs Zinus is the next logical step. Once done, you can log-on to Amazon and get the option you picked delivered to you. However, you don’t have to research on your own. We’ve already done that. All you need is to read through the comparative information we have provided about the two beds below and pick a winner.

Quick Comparison

Both of these mattress manufacturers have made names for themselves, giving people many beds to choose from. As such if neither of these mattresses appeals to you, Zinus and LUCID have other options that you can look into. Also, there are things that you should be on the lookout for when evaluating a foam mattress. The type of foam used is one such example. Lucid, for instance, uses a gel-infused variation of memory foam in their mattress.

On the other hand, Zinus quotes the foam in their mattress as being green tea memory foam, which should have its advantage over other variations. Also, the Zinus is pricier than the LUCID. Where budget is one of your key considerations for purchasing a bed, this makes the LUCID seem more appealing. You should again be aware of the firmness rating for these beds. As a rule of thumb always ensure any mattresses, you purchase now and in the future range between 5.5 and 7.5. This is usually a sweet spot for most people. This Zinus option ranks at a six while its counterpart the LUCID ranks at 6.5. With the LUCID being a bit more firm, it comes down to preference as to how plush you want your bed to be.

ZinusLUCID
  • 12-inch thickness
  • 75-pound weight
  • ActivCharcoal particles in the design
  • Green tea for neutralizing odor
  • Gel memory foam construction
  • Box shipping
  • Compatibility with all bed types
  • 10-inch thickness
  • 55-pound weight
  • 10-year warranty
  • Gel memory foam construction
  • Box shipping
  • Compatibility with all bed types

Mattress specifications

Zinus Green TeaLUCID
TypeFoamFoam
FirmnessMedium firm (6)Medium-Firm (6.5)
Thickness12″10″
Weight75.1 lbs55 lbs
Sleep trial100 nights
Warranty5 years10 years
Price (Queen)$392$240 (Queen)
CertificationCertiPUR-USCerti-PUR-US

Construction

Zinus Green TeaLUCID
Support core3.5″ high-density foam
3.5’’ base high-density foam
7.5″ High-Density Support Foam
Comfort layers3″ comfort foam
2″ gel-infused memory foam
2.5″ Gel Memory Foam
Coverknitted JacuardTencel Blend

As indicated on the table above the two mattresses are quite different. The LUCID bed totals two layers in addition to the mattress cover. The support core takes the most significant chunk of the bed with 7.5 inches out of the 10. Of course, all that is left is the 2.5-inch comfort layer, and this is where the gel memory foam is incorporated. Memory foam helps the mattress conform to your body shape, and you will thus see it in a lot of bed offerings. When infused with Gel, the effect is heat wicking capabilities that should thus help individuals sleep cooler. The Zinus mattress has four total component layers, with two acting as the support core, while the other two focus on comfort. The bed also incorporates gel-infused memory foam as one of the components. The top covers from both picks are also made from breathable materials.

Comfort

Given the rising popularity of these two options, you can expect them to be quite comfortable. However, many factors go into determining whether a mattress is suitable for a particular individual. Here characteristics of the sleeper also come into play. Things like the weight of the sleeper can be influential on the comfort of the bed. Next up is the individual’s preferred sleeping position. The main three options include sleeping on your back, your stomach and your sides. Most people prefer one of the three, but sometimes they switch positions in their sleep. However, the bed also has to do its part in ensuring optimum comfort. Characteristics listed below are the critical ones that help mattresses do that.

Firmness and support

Zinus vs LUCID: Which Is Better for You?On a scale of one through ten, there are usually varying levels of firmness in between. One, of course, represents the softest value while ten is the highest bordering on hard. If a mattress is so soft that your whole body sinks into it, your spine is not aligned as you sleep. In addition to being uncomfortable, it may result in long term spine damage if you keep sleeping on such a mattress for a long time. On the other end, resting on a hard surface is not much better. Your spine will still be out of alignment, and you will be uncomfortable as you sleep. Consequently, the established sweet spot is between 5.5 and 7.5, which most foam manufacturers try to adhere to.

The options mentioned above are at varying degrees of the established sweet spot and so won’t damage your spine as you sleep. However, you, as the buyer, ought to know yourself and whether you prefer softer or firmer. If the former is your answer, you would be best served by the Zinus bed and vice versa with the LUCID mattress.

Temperature control

You also want a bed that can help regulate temperatures while you sleep. You don’t want to wake up with your sheets soaked because it got a little too hot while you were sleeping and now you are dripping in sweat. The Zinus and LUCID do what they can to keep you sleeping cool. LUCID’s 10-inch mattress features a ventilated design for airflow in and out of your bed, which should do an excellent job of temperature control. The Zinus 12-inch, on the other hand, also has gel memory foam, which should have similar effects with that of the LUCID. In addition to that, the Zinus manufacturer input tiny particles of purified charcoal in the bed. These serve to wick away heat and moisture while a person rests. As such the Zinus holds a slight lead over its opponent feature-wise.

Motion transfer

Here you can bet on both mattresses to perform pretty much the same. They both have memory foam in their top layers. The top layer will thus localize any adjustments a person makes as they sleep to the area they are sleeping on.

Responsiveness

Zinus vs LUCID: Which Is Better for You?Also, another characteristic of the top memory foam layer is that responsiveness is limited. Some people see this as an advantage as the bed conforms slowly to your figure once you lay on it. Fast response time may come as a shock as it often involves sinking into the mattress and some bounce. However, this is not for all people.

Resilience and bounce

Resilience is a critical factor in almost any mattress. It even influences how long a mattress will last. Usually, the bottom support cores of the mattresses boost the resilience. They are firmer than their comfort layer counterparts. Also, where latex foam is concerned, you might see a bit of bounce. However, with the two mattresses in question, the responsiveness has already been determined to be minimal since it is memory foam. As such you can also expect bounce to be the same way.

Edge support

Foam mattresses rarely have any edge support. You, therefore, shouldn’t expect the LUCID and Zinus beds to do well in this area.

Off-gassing and smell

Once you have the mattress in your house, you will notice that it was compressed so it could fit in a box. You will also smell a weird odor from the bed. What you should do to solve this problem is to remove the beds from their casings, spread them out and wait. If possible, do this in a well-aerated room in the house. The mattresses will expand, and soon enough, the smell will be gone. This process roughly takes a few days. Nonetheless, for the Zinus, the odor dissemination period is likely to be shorter.

Sleep position ratings

SLEEP POSITIONLight sleepers(less than 130 lbs)Average sleepers(130 lbs to 230 lbs)Heavy sleepers(greater than 230 lbs)
Zinus Green Tea
Side796
Back877
Stomach1086
LUCID
Side799
Back91010
Stomach899*

*Out of 10

With the three sleeping positions, both mattresses perform reasonably well garnering seven out of ten points and above. However, on average, the LUCID mattress is a better all-round performer than its Zinus counterpart. This is especially visible with average and heavy sleepers who prefer laying on their backs as they all rate the Zinus mattress at ten while the same people in the same sleeping positions rate the LUCID at 10. Where the LUCID performs, lowest is for people lighter than 130 lbs who prefer laying on their sides. This performance is mirrored in the Zinus for the same demographic.

Sizes and pricing

SIZEZinus Green TeaLUCID
Twin$188$221
Twin XL$170
Full$295$199
Queen$233$240
King$503$304
California King$350$350

Customer service

Sleep trialWarranty and refundDelivery
Zinus Green Tea100 days5-year warrantyfull refundWithin the U.S.
LUCID10 yearsWithin the U.S.

 

Sleep trial

You possibly want to experience the mattress for a couple of nights so you can judge for yourself if it’s worth the buy. Most manufacturers don’t do that but what they do is allow you to take it on a test run after you’ve bought it. If after that, you are unsatisfied with how it feels you can return it to the vendor and get your money back. However, the sleep trial for the LUCID is non-existent. If you must have that option, the Zinus offers up to 100 days after which you can’t return the product unless for warranty issues.

Warranty and refund

Warranty covering any damage to the mattress is there for the Zinus and LUCID options. For the former, you get five years whereby if there is a claim you get a 100% refund. LUCID, on the other hand, offer a warranty period twice that long; however, theirs might have a few expenses. You will still get most of your money back just not all of it.

Delivery

The two companies manufacture mattresses for the same market in the United States. Anybody wanting to purchase these products from the rest of the world would have to pay for delivery out of pocket. This would make the mattresses much more expensive than they currently are and as a result, most people outside the U.S.A. don’t buy the beds. On the other hand, within the country, delivery is free for both options.

So which should you buy?

PROS:
  • Better temperature control properties
  • Green tea properties neutralize odors emitted by the mattress faster
  • Conforms to all bed types
  • Offers a sleep trial

CONS:
  • Back sleepers of average and heavy build are not too comfortable with the bed

PROS:
  • Has better overall comfort ratings than its counterpart
  • 10-year warranty
  • Free shipping

CONS:
  • No sleep trial

In conclusion

Both picks are solid beds, and you could barely go wrong by purchasing either one of them. Nevertheless, you still have to pick a mattress from the two. If you pick out the attributes that you like in a foam mattress from the ones we have listed above, you can assign a value to each. Adding these values could give you an overall score. This would make it easier to choose as the one with the higher score is better suited for your needs. As such, making an informed choice has never been easier. We leave the rest up to you.

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

      Leave a reply

      Pin It on Pinterest

      Login/Register access is temporary disabled