Talk About Sleep is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here
Amerisleep and Purple are two well-known names in the mattress industry, and even though both of them offer high-quality mattresses, they are quite different in terms of feel and firmness options, materials and construction, price and more. We picked these two brands to review and compare because of their characteristics and versatility that make them ideal for most kinds of sleepers. Our Amerisleep vs. Purple comparison includes conclusions drawn from testing and researching the most popular mattress models from the two brands, including those who have received constant high ratings from the consumers. While Amerisleep mattresses have a line of memory foam mattresses that has proved excellent for most types of sleepers, Purple is well-known for its unique materials that make it stand out from the competition. We are going over the main similarities and differences below so you can easily make your choice when it comes to Amerisleep vs. Purple.
Amerisleep is a leading brand on the mattress market, specializing in quality memory foam mattresses. The company offers multiple firmness levels to suit the needs of all types of sleepers, as well as free shipping and a convenient return policy. On the other hand, Purple mattresses come in only two models, focusing on pressure relieving that provides users with a unique feel. Their original offering includes hybrid mattresses that conform closely to the sensitive points of the body. As for the price tag, the two brands offer mattresses with prices starting from $649 for Purple and $1,099 for Amerisleep, respectively, but this depends on the size of the mattress you choose.
Multiple firmness options
Most models come with motion isolation
Use of celliant fiber in the cover for body temperature regulation
20-year low cost warranty
Minimal motion transfer
Effective at minimizing pressure points and relieving back pain
Sleeps cooler than other memory foam mattresses on the market
3.5″ 1.8 lbs density polyurethane foam
2″ Hyper-Elastic Polymer™ material in Smart Comfort Grid™
Amerisleep offers five types of memory foam mattresses, each of them featuring a slightly different construction to cater to the needs of different sleepers. All of them come with a celliant cover for a cooler sleeping environment, as well as a bio-based memory foam top layer that contributes to pressure relief. Four of the five models feature a transition polyfoam layer to ease the transition to the firm base layer, which is made from standard polyfoam.
On the other hand, the construction of Purple mattresses is slightly different, as the top layer is made from 2 inches of hyper-elastic polymer that gives your body pressure relief where it needs it. This makes the mattress feel firm, yet pressure-relieving at the same time, which makes it an excellent choice for side sleepers. The middle layer is made from 1.8 lb. density transition poly foam to provide an easy transition to the firm base layer, which is 4 inches of 2.0 lb. density poly foam.
Both Amerisleep and Purple mattresses are designed with promoting uninterrupted sleep in mind, and they both manage to achieve this purpose admirably. Because they keep your body in proper alignment while providing proper spine support, these mattresses combine the best of both worlds when it comes to comfortable mattresses: excellent support and firmness.
Memory foam mattresses made by Amerisleep and Purple offer firm support for your back and spinal column while also doing a great job at providing soft pressure relief for your shoulders and hips. Moreover, the comfort level is enhanced by the fact that they are made with temperature control in mind, which improves the quality of your sleep no matter the season.
Firmness and support
Amerisleep mattresses come in five models, each of them with a different level of firmness and support for your back and spine. The AS1 model is a straight firm, the AS2 has slightly more give, the AS3 lands around a medium-firm, whereas the AS4 to AS5 are softer on the firmness scale, which makes them a good choice for side sleepers. When choosing the firmness of the mattress, you need to take into account the type of sleeper you are, as well as your size. According to Amerisleep, side sleepers would fare best with the AS4 because it falls on the medium-soft scale, whereas those who spend most of their night on their back and stomach may benefit most from the AS2 mattress. Finally, those who are looking for a versatile mattress that suits all types of sleepers should look at the AS3 Amerisleep mattress.
The top layer polymer grid of the Purple mattresses makes them unique on the market, as this design allows the mattress to shift its shape as you move on it, offering you back and spinal support just like a firm mattress. This design can be particularly useful for sleepers who tend to suffer from shoulder, hip, or back pain. The comfortable support and firmness are completed by excellent bounciness and motion isolation, which makes the mattress perfect for couples.
When it comes to temperature control, our test and most of the reviews we encountered delivered Purple mattresses as the winner between the two brands. These mattresses are living up to their cool sleeping claims, as they do not hold heat the way memory foam mattresses do. The design of the Purple mattresses promotes airflow and prevents moisture, which means that you can remain cool all night long no matter the climate you live in.
However, many customers mention that even though Amerisleep mattresses are memory foam ones, they don’t actually sleep too hot. While they may not provide the same level of temperature control as Purple mattresses, they still provide you with a more temperature neutral experience.
Both Amerisleep and Purple mattresses will work just fine for couples, as they do a good job at limiting motion transfer. This means that you won’t feel much of your partner’s movements throughout the night.
The Bio-Pur memory used in the construction of Amerisleep mattresses makes them more responsive than traditional memory foam mattresses. When it comes to Purple mattresses, you should expect a good level of responsiveness that helps with ease of repositioning.
Resilience and bounce
The resilience and bounce of a mattress are important because they contribute to the feeling of sinking you experience with the mattress. The bounce of the Purple mattresses is a superior one, and most users mentioned that the polymer material used in the construction of the mattress provides a bounce that is similar to that of a latex mattress. According to Amerisleep, their mattresses bounce back in just four seconds (tested for the AS3 model), which is very quick, taking into account the fact that traditional memory foam mattresses may take around 60 seconds to bounce back.
Edge support is important when you share a bed with a partner, because you will want your mattress to be able to support weight near the side well. Amerisleep mattresses have a good edge support in firmer models, while the softer ones may have a little trouble when you hang off the side of the bed. When you sit on the mattress, you may be able to fell that the poly foam layers do a good job at supporting your weight, even though you may feel some compression through the first layer. When it comes to Purple mattresses, the edge support is about average, as you will notice a bit of compression when you roll towards the edge of the bed.
Inflation time, off-gassing and smell
Inflation time refers to the time required for the mattress to achieve its normal form after you unbox it. With Purple mattresses, you should expect the mattress to reach its form immediately, but nevertheless, the manufacturer mentions that you may experience an adjustment period of two to four weeks. This happens because it takes a while to your body to adjust to the new mattress if it is out of alignment. For Amerisleep mattresses, you should expect an inflation period of up to eight hours until the corners expand fully. The manufacturer mentions that you can lay on the mattress straight away, but you should wait for two hours before putting sheets on.
When it comes to off-gassing and smell, Amerisleep mattresses may have a slight smell that may last up to 48 hours. This is due to the breaking down of VOC, but in any case, many users mentioned that the smell is very faint when compared to that of traditional foam mattresses. A “new mattress smell” is to be expected with Purple mattresses as well, but if should fade in a couple of days.
Sleep position ratings
(less than 130 lbs)
(130 lbs to 230 lbs)
(greater than 230 lbs)
*Out of 10
Amerisleep mattresses work perfectly for petite and average-sized sleepers but are not as great of a choice for heavy sleepers. On the other hand, Purple mattresses would be an excellent option for heavy sleepers over 230 lbs. Back sleepers would find Amerisleep mattresses ideal no matter their size, whereas Purple mattresses fare better for smaller-sized side sleepers and larger-size back sleepers
Sizes and pricing
Warranty and refund
All 48 contiguous states
Within the U.S. and Canada
Both Amerisleep and Purple mattresses offer sleep trials so you can test the mattress before deciding whether to keep it. Amerisleep offers customers a 100-night trial, so you can have as much time as possible to test the mattress. This way, you can evaluate the benefits of the mattress better than in a showroom. If you are not satisfied with the mattress, you can get a refund as long as you request it before the 100 nights are over. The mattress will be collected from your home for free even if you don’t have the packaging anymore and will be recycled or donated to a local charity. Purple mattresses also come with a 100-night trial and free returns.
Warranty and refund
Amerisleep mattresses offer a 20-year limited warranty, which is partially prorated. This means that you will get a replacement or repair during the first 10 years of ownership at no extra charge. For years 11 to 20, you can get a replacement for defective mattresses in the value of 50 percent of the original price. During this period, you will be responsible for transportation costs.
Purple offers a 10-year warranty that is nonprorated, so you can get it repair or replaced if it is defective as long as you have a valid warranty. Purple warranty only covers defective mattresses and not damage done via negligence or improper use.
Amerisleep mattresses are delivered compressed and vacuum-sealed in a box that varies in size and weight according to the model and size of mattress you choose. You can order a mattress, and have it delivered free of charge in all 48 states and selected overseas locations. Most deliveries are via FedEx and you should expect your new mattress to be with you in three to five working days.
All Purple mattresses except for the New Purple model are also delivered compressed and vacuum-sealed in a box. The New Purple model ships with white glove delivery free of charge and free in-home setup. Purple mattresses ship in the United States and Canada and they are delivered in five working days. If you want your new mattress quicker than that, you can pay for expedited delivery and have it delivered in two days.
Amerisleep and Purple do not currently offer a trade-in program when you buy a new mattress.
Ideal for all body types, including individuals over 250 lbs.
Only been in business since 2016, which means we can’t know about long-term durability
Edge support is rather poor
Now that you have gone over our Amerisleep vs. Purple comparison, you can make an informed decision to improve the quality of your sleep. To sum it up, if it’s a memory foam mattress you’re after, you can’t go wrong with Amerisleep. However, if you are interested in buying a high-quality cool-sleeping mattress, Purple is a hot sleeper’s dream. Purple also offers better support for those who weigh around 230 lbs. or more, but if you want an extended 20-year warranty, Amerisleep is an excellent choice.