Tuft & Needle vs Amerisleep: Which Is Better for You?

Can't decide between Tuft and Needle and Amerisleep? We compared them for you.
Last updated: October 17, 2020
0 comments
vs
Can't decide between Tuft and Needle and Amerisleep? We compared them for you.
50 Hours of Research
5 Experts Interviewed
202 Reviews Analyzed

A good mattress is crucial for getting the all important rest and relaxation. In recent years, memory foam has gone from being a novelty to a desirable alternative to the traditional spring bed. Memory foam is hypoallergenic and discourages dust mites, but it also provides pressure point relief and supports proper spine alignment to avoid waking up stiff and sore. Two brands who are leading the market for memory foam mattresses are Tuft & Needle and Amerisleep. So, before you consider buying your next mattress, here we’ll perform a Tuft & Needle vs Amerisleep comparison to help you make an informed purchase decision.

Quick Comparison

The Tuft & Needle brand was launched in 2012 as a consequence of a lousy mattress shopping experience. The brand now offers mattresses, pillows, and other bed accessories. The Tuft & Needle mattresses are designed with medium firm foam, and offer a ten-year warranty despite the more modest price tag.

Amerisleep is a more established brand and the company aims to lead the transformation of the mattress industry. The Amerisleep mattresses are made to offer medium support with an ecofriendly VPF process to manufacture all foam for the products that are completely produced in the U.S. While the Amerisleep mattress is costlier, the brand does offer a more extensive warranty covering 20 years from the date of purchase.

Tuft & NeedleAmerisleep
  • Adaptive Foam to provide bounce and support.
  • High Grade, Sleep Cool foam for greater comfort
  • Made in the USA
  • Pressure кelieving to adapt to your body
  • 12” Profile to offer versatile support for changing sleep positions
  • Bio Core for sag free support
  • 3” Bio Pur cooling layer
  • Made in the USA with Patented VPF technology
  • Plush firmness

Mattress specifications

Tuft & NeedleAmerisleep
TypeFoamFoam
FirmnessMedium firm (6.5)Medium (5.5)
Thickness10″12″
Weight71 lbs96 lbs
Sleep trial100 nights100 nights
Warranty10 years20 years
Price$595 (Queen)$1,399 (Queen)
CertificationGreenguard Gold
Standard 100 by OEKO-TEX
Certi-PUR-US
CertiPUR-US
Meets Clean Air Act standards

Construction

Tuft & NeedleAmerisleep
Support core7″ 1.8 PCF HD polyfoam2″ 1.65 PCF polyfoam
7″ 1.8 PCF polyfoam
Comfort layers3″ 2.8 PCF polyfoam3″ 4 PCF memory foam
CoverMicro polyamide and polyester77% Polyester
21% Celliant
2% Spandex

While the Tuft & Needle has a 10” thickness, the Amerisleep has an additional 2 inches. This provides an extra layer to prevent sagging and offer greater support for those who tend to change positions frequently while sleeping. Both models claim to offer a cooling effect to avoid that hot clammy feeling associated with latex foam, but the Amerisleep has a dedicated 3” thick Bio Pur cooling layer.

Comfort

Tuft & Needle vs Amerisleep: Which Is Better for You?Memory foam mattresses are designed to support improved spinal alignment and pressure point relief, but both the Tuft & Needle and Amerisleep take this one step further. Tuft & Needle claim to use more advanced materials that provide “the right mix” of softness and support to avoid sinking in and feeling stuck.

Amerisleep claims that each mattress is produced with a finely tuned construction of layers to create as much comfort as possible including an active response layer to prevent sagging and internal channels for increased pressure redistribution and greater airflow.

Firmness and support

The Tuft & Needle is classified as offering medium support, while the Amerisleep is plush. In real terms, this means that both mattresses are designed to offer a balance of soft comfort and solid support. Unlike some other foam mattresses, both models will not create a sagging or sinking feeling that will leave you feeling uncomfortable every time you want to change position.

Temperature control

Tuft & Needle vs Amerisleep: Which Is Better for You?Foam mattresses have a reputation for creating an uncomfortably hot sleep environment. However, both Tuft & Needle and Amerisleep have thought to remedy this. The Tuft & Needle model uses “advanced” high grade foam to “sleep cool” with a gel graphite blend, while Amerisleep has included a dedicated cooling layer to maintain optimum temperature control. The Amerisleep mattress also features a Celliant cover that is designed to convert body heat emitted during sleep into infrared to help you wake up feeling refreshed and rejuvenated.

Motion transfer

In practice, good quality memory foam should have minimum motion transfer to help avoid disturbing your partner if you’re tossing and turning. While both mattresses are said to offer support for changing positions, only Tuft & Needle specifically address motion transfer to your sleep partner. The adaptive foam used is designed to offer a localized bounce to help prevent disturbing your sleeping partner. This should also eliminate roll for sleep partners who differ in size and weight.

Responsiveness

Since both the Tuft & Needle and Amerisleep are both higher quality memory foam, you won’t find that the top layer will not contour to your body like traditional memory foam. However, this does not mean that the mattresses do not offer excellent responsiveness. The Tuft & Needle features adaptive foam to provide soft comfort and support, while the Amerisleep has been designed to offer versatile support for changing sleep positions.

Resilience and bounce

Tuft & Needle vs Amerisleep: Which Is Better for You?Tuft & Needle claim that its mattress offers localized bounce for additional comfort with a high resilience. Amerisleep has more of a plush construction with multiple layers to provide contour and support. Neither mattress has that sinking in feeling that you’ll find with cheaper latex memory foam mattresses.

Edge support

Many people tend to sit on the edge of their bed, and this means that you need adequate edge support to prevent sagging, particularly with memory foam mattresses. The Amerisleep Bio Core is designed to offer support throughout the mattress, which provides more edge support than many other memory foam mattresses. Unfortunately, many users report the Tuft & Needle mattress as having questionable edge support, which means that sinking can occur over time along the perimeter of the bed.

Inflation time, off-gassing and smell

Both mattresses may require off gassing, but you can expect any odors to quickly dissipate. Tuft & Needle recommend allowing up to 72 hours for full expansion of the mattress and to allow any odors to completely dissipate. Amerisleep ship its mattresses compressed in an eco-friendly package and it needs to be unrolled and allowed to expand for approximately 4 to 6 hours before use, but it can take as long as 24 hours for full expansion.

Sleep position ratings

SLEEP POSITIONLight sleepers(less than 130 lbs)Average sleepers(130 lbs to 230 lbs)Heavy sleepers(greater than 230 lbs)
Tuft & Needle
Sidefairvery goodgood
Backvery goodgoodvery good
Stomachfairgoodgood
Amerisleep
Sidegoodvery goodgood
Backvery goodvery goodvery good
Stomachvery goodgoodgood

Sizes and pricing

SIZETuft & NeedleAmerisleep
Twin$350$1,099
Twin XL$395$1,149
Full$495$1,249
Queen$595$1,399
King$750$1,699
California King$750$1,699
Split KingN/A$2,098

Customer service

Sleep trialWarranty and refundDelivery
Tuft & Needle100 nights10-year warrantyfull refundWithin the U.S.
Amerisleep100 days20-year warrantyfull refund48 contiguous states

Both Tuft & Needle and Amerisleep offer a 100-day sleep trial, but while T&N offer a 10-year warranty, Amerisleep has a 20-year warranty. However, Tuft & Needle have no restrictions on when you can return a mattress, but Amerisleep has a 30-night minimum for eligibility.

Both companies ship mattresses compressed in packaging, but Amerisleep put an emphasis on the fact that its packaging is eco-friendly.

So which should you buy?

Tuft & Needle

PROS:
  • Less costly
  • Good motion isolation
  • Free shipping for contiguous U.S

CONS:
  • Shorter 10-year Warranty
  • Questionable edge support

Amerisleep

PROS:
  • 20-year warranty
  • Celliant fiber cover offering some health benefits
  • Free shipping
  • Above average motion isolation

CONS:
  • Higher initial purchase cost
  • Mandatory break-in period to qualify for sleep trial

In conclusion

While both mattresses do have some excellent features, in the Tuft & Needle vs Amerisleep comparison, Amerisleep does come out on top. The brand offers greater product support and while there is a 30-night minimum for the sleep trial, the 20-year warranty more than compensates for this. The mattress has innovative technology to create a cool and comfortable place to rest with pressure point relief, proper spinal alignment support and Celliant fiber cover to further enhance your sleep experience.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Pin It on Pinterest