Marcus is an orthopedic spine surgeon who knows for sure how to ease ache in your back, neck, and shoulders, and prevent meeting him in person.
Last updated: May 27, 2021
Talk About Sleep is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here
Tempur-Pedic is often touted as the best memory foam mattress company. However, as you would expect, their mattresses are very expensive. Luxury mattresses here can cost up to $4,500! But good quality mattresses like the brand offers aren’t limited to Tempurpedic alone. From WinkBed to Bear, Molecule, and Amerisleep, there are a lot of mattress brands springing up and fastly becoming viable competitors.
Hence, without necessarily being as expensive, the mattresses from these other competitors possess similar quality and features, such as Tempurpedic offers. By taking a look at the sizes available, the material, firmness, warranty, among other features, we reviewed the best Tempurpedic alternative mattresses on the market and ranked them on our list of favorites. So, keep reading to find out!
The WinkBed is our option of the overall best Tempurpedic mattress alternative. It’s a bed with three different firmness options and a plus option for heavier individuals. Starting with the cover, it’s made of Tencel, a material that is very soft and known for being a very breathable material. Regarding the layers of the mattress, WinkBed is a hybrid mattress. This means they combine foam and coil layers. The mattress is made in the United States. In addition, there’s a 120-night trial and a lifetime limited warranty.
The mattress is designed for those who want pressure relief. The top layers are foam layers. Starting with a hyper soft foam up top helps with pressure relief. This also adds some bounce to it. So you don’t feel like you’re going to get stuck in the mattress. The layer below is a gel layer that contours the body and also help with motion transfer. There are also micro coils that help improve airflow and also isolate motion transfer. The coils help with airflow through the mattress, so you don’t sleep too hot. Within the coil, a layer is a lumbar support layer that helps keep up your lower back, so you feel support there.
Why did it make our list?
We think the mattress would be good for you if you had liked pillowtop mattresses in the past. WinkBed takes that to the next level also if you're looking for a little extra support, which we like. The coil structure of the hybrid mattress delivers better support than strictly foam mattresses. If you're worried about sleeping too hot, not only does the coil structure allow for increased airflow, WinkBeds also offer accessory options for temperature regulation.
What is not ideal about it?
The only downside is they only deliver within the United States. They don't deliver outside of the US, except you use a package forwarder. However, quality-wise, there is no downside to this. If you reside in the US, shipping is free, and you can receive the mattress in 7 to 14 business days.
Amerisleep is well known for its lineup of memory foam beds. In quality, it has some of the best alternatives to Tempurpedic mattresses. The Organica is their latex hybrid mattress option. This mattress comes with a free bed in box shipping.
The Organica mattress is between a medium and a medium-firm on our scale. This means it’s going to be generally accommodating for all sleeper types: back, the stomach is a side, and combination sleepers. We think it’s going to be especially good for combination sleepers because that latex foam is very bouncy, and responsive switching between sleeping positions is effortless.
Why are we impressed?
What we liked most about the mattress is its pocketed coil system. This system does a better job of isolating motion. Also, the coils on Organica features a zone support system. This means the coils are going to provide you with a bit more support where you carry the majority of your weight and a bit more pressure relief in other areas like your shoulders.
What negatives must you be aware of?
We think the mattress might be too firm for strict side sleepers. Lighter side sleepers generally want a softer mattress that helps cradle their pressure points. If you're a lighter individual, you generally feel beds be a bit firmer because you're putting less pressure on the mattress.
The Evolution 15 is a hybrid mattress. It has a combination of foam and coils. It consists of a proprietary foam called the AirFoamICE™. This is a heavy mattress: each side has two handles that are stitched with the end of the mattress. They are very useful in installing the mattress and carrying it around to adjust it. The top two inches of the mattress let heat escape. The top two inches have a gusset that is engineered to keep the heat away. It is a hybrid mattress, so you have a combination of coils and foam.
It’s going to be a great option for side sleepers especially. It also works relatively well for back sleepers as well as the combo sleepers that might fall asleep on their side and wake up on their back.
Why did it make our list?
The Nolah Evolution 15 has a high thermal conductivity that is going to grab the heat emitted by your body and conduct it down inside its top layer. We liked how it keeps the body cool at night by getting you rid of the heat instead of trapping the heat underneath you and then heating you.
What is not ideal about it?
The downside is it's on the heavier side. We, therefore, recommend two adults to install this mattress. The Nolah Evolution is a 15-inch-thick mattress which is one of the thickest mattresses that we have here. It will rise to its full size instantly once you unpack it.
The Molecule Hybrid Mattress comes with a 100-night free trial. If you don’t want it, you get free returns within the first three months of using it. Also, Molecule mattresses come with a lifetime warranty. The mattress is about 13 inches thick, across all sizes, whether King, Queen, Twin, Full, Twin XL, or California King. It’s a hybrid mattress that has three layers of foam. The layers consist of the proprietary layer, the MOLECULEedge™ coils, the AirTEC™ foam, and the 100% Polyurethane foam layer.
The hybrid mattress is like a traditional Tempur-pedic mattress. This particular model is somewhere between a medium and a medium firm and around five to a seven on the soft or firm scale. It’s great for all sleeping positions.
What stands out?
The mattress is very temperature neutral. What this means is its temperature regulating. You're not going to sleep overly hot or overly cold. So, it's great for all types of seasons.
What cons did we manage to find?
We liked the fact the mattress is great for back and stomach sleepers. But it's not as good for strict side sleepers.
The Bear Pro is a memory foam bed. It feels like a big slab of soft foam. So, if you prefer something more traditional, you have to choose the Bear Pro. It’s flat-out one of the most comfortable beds we have seen recently. We put Bear Pro at about a medium-firm when it comes to firmness. This means it should be good for stomach, side, combination, and back sleepers.
Compared to the Bear Purple, the Bear Pro might be a little bit more expensive. However, after the discount, they’re both around the $900 to $1,000 range. Also, the Bear Pro are beds that should be accommodating for all sleeping positions.
What makes it stand out?
What we like most is the guarantee that comes with the mattress. You have ten years warranty on the mattress. Once the mattress is delivered to your house, you have 100 nights to test it out. So, you have at least three months to figure out if they're what you're looking for. You'll be able to know if it's the right softness, firmness, or the right feel profile for you.
Which disadvantages must you keep in mind?
We think it's not great for lightweight sleepers. For this category of sleepers, the Bear mattress will be more preferable. Also, the mattress is a bit expensive. It's not for those looking for a low-budget alternative to Tempurpedic mattresses.
The Awara mattress is natural and organic. It has a hybrid construction that mixes latex foam and coils. Awara is a total of 13 inches thick, and it has a simple construction; nine-inch pocketed coils topped by 4 inches of organic natural Dunlop latex foam. It also has organic cotton and natural wool cover.
Natural latex does have some inherent benefits, like being antimicrobial and having natural insect repellent. So, this makes the mattress great for anyone with allergies. The mattress helps prevent dust mites and other allergens from taking up residence in your mattress. Latex foam is also cooler than other foams. It gets better airflow, and it doesn’t trap heat like memory foam often does. Therefore, it’s a good material for hot sleepers to consider. It’s also a great option for heavier people in the 250 pounds plus range.
What are our favorite features?
You will get a whole year to try this mattress, and if at any point within that 365-night trial period, you decide it's not for you, you can return it for a full refund, and then if you do keep the mattress, it's backed by a forever warranty. It comes compressed and rolled in a bag rather than a box. You just have to go take it out, roll it out on your bed frame, remove the wrapping, and that's it.
What could be better?
The mattress could be less expensive. However, we would ask you to go for it, especially if you're willing to pay a little more for organic materials.
Things to Consider
When it comes to buying a mattress, many consumers are unsure which model is best. To make your decision easier, we have put together an informative buying guide to help you order a Tempurpedic alternative mattress.
Advantages of Tempurpedic Alternatives
As with those made by Tempurpedic, there are also advantages and disadvantages with Tempur alternative mattresses. Of course, personal experiences and opinions always play an important role, but you should also take a closer look at the mattresses objectively.
These mattresses are developed from high-quality material so that they are not only viscose but also elastic. Thus, the mattresses ensure important support for the relevant parts of the body and remain flexible so that they can adapt to your body at any time.
The material of the Tempur alternative mattresses is not only pressure-relieving but also forms back at any time so that no hollows remain. The various manufacturers offer their customers long quality guarantees, from 100 to 365-night guarantees, such as with the Awara Organic Mattress. The mattresses are also designed to compensate for different demands on hardness and softness.
Finally, these types of mattresses are not as expensive as Tempurpedic mattresses. While Tempurpedic mattresses range from $1,000 to upwards of $4,500, the average price range of their alternatives is around the $700 to $1,500 range.
Features to Consider Before You Buy a Tempurpedic Alternative
The mattress has a great influence on a night of restful sleep, but only if it supports your body optimally. Here you will find an overview with important criteria to consider to make your decision-making process easier.
Different mattress sizes are recommended for couples, singles, or children. Factors such as body size, space in your bedroom, and sleeping habits are also decisive for the purchase. All mattresses are available in different sizes.
Single mattress: Most singles with little space in the apartment choose a size of 100 or 120 by 200 centimeters. However, if you often sleep in pairs on the mattress, you should get a wider version, ideally with a width of 140 or 160 cm.
Mattress for children: For children and adolescents, a smaller size, around 80 or 90 by 200 centimeters, is sufficient. For children’s beds, there are mattress sizes of 60 by 120 or 70 by 140 cm in stores.
Mattress for couples: The majority of all couples choose a mattress size of 160 or 180 by 200 centimeters so that everyone has enough space for a restful sleep. However, if a partner moves more frequently during sleep, a larger mattress of 200 by 200 cm is appropriate. The same applies if the child or pet likes to sneak into bed with you at night. Conversely, for those who like to lie close together, a width of 140 cm is sufficient.
Alternatively, these are categorized into sizes known as King, Queen, California King, Full, Twin, Twin XL, and more.
Mattresses differ mainly in terms of their structure and the materials used. Depending on the mattress core, i.e., spring core, foam, or latex, the models have different lying properties.
Spring core mattresses: Spring mattresses are available in several designs or springs: from the Bonell spring core to the pocket spring core to the barrel pocket spring core. What they all have in common is their inner structure made of steel spring cores, which give way when the load is applied and return to their original shape when the load is removed. There is a protective layer of felt or fleece over the spring core. This shields the upholstery from any damage caused by the springs. The cushion on top ensures that consumers do not feel the springs of the innerspring mattress uncomfortably in their backs.
Latex mattresses: These are allergy-friendly ones. Latex, which is originally obtained from rubber trees, is now mainly produced synthetically. The quality of a latex mattress (upper price level) depends on the composition of the materials used. There are three types; natural latex with a rubber content of at least 75 percent, a mixture of natural and synthetic latex with a rubber content below 75 percent.
Foam mattresses: These are the flexible ones. Conventional foam mattresses are still the classic in children’s rooms. The standard foam, also known as comfort foam, consists of a single block of polyurethane that has an uneven foam structure and strength but adapts well to the contours of the body. Until the invention of cold foam, foam mattresses were not considered to be particularly durable. However, it has now become the most popular type of mattress.
Cold foam mattresses: The cold foam mattress (mostly inexpensive mattresses) is, as the name suggests, produced by cold foaming and the subsequent pressing of polyurethane foam. This allows a more even distribution of hardness than with the comfort foam mattress. In the course of the quality improvement, the cold foam is not only point-elastic but also very stable. Cold foam, therefore, offers perfect sleeping or lying comfort.
Even restless sleepers get their money’s worth with a cold foam mattress, as the springy material enables effortless turning. In addition, cold foam mattresses are completely noise-free so that, for example, couples with different movement patterns can sleep undisturbed.
Visco-elastic mattresses: Visco-elastic mattresses (medium price) are made of so-called memory foam, which was originally developed for astronauts. Its thermosensitive properties help them to adjust their spacesuit precisely to the body. Visco foam reacts to pressure as well as to heat so that it adapts exactly to the shape of the body; it is also highly elastic – but with a significant delay. If you press a hand into the foam, it leaves a recognizable impression that remains for a longer period. Since the material reacts very slowly, it is more suitable for quiet sleepers. Restless sleep types, on the other hand, are restricted in their freedom of movement due to the brief depressions that occur. A typical example of a memory foam mattress is the Bear PRO Mattress.
Tempur offers different mattresses so that the degree of hardness and the feeling of sleep can vary. This is, however, imitated by competitors. The hardness of a mattress can be determined by many factors: The height of the foam layers, the density of the foams used, and the quality of the foam types should be examined more closely.
Usually, however, mattress manufacturers classify in degrees of hardness from H1 to H5.
H1 degree of hardness has a perceived hardness classified as soft and is recommended for weight class of up to 60 kilograms. H2 degree of hardness has a perceived hardness classified as medium and is recommended for weight class of up to 80 kilograms.
H3 degree of hardness has a perceived hardness classified as hard and is recommended for weight class of up to 100 kilograms. H4 degree of hardness has a perceived hardness classified as extra firm and is recommended for weight class of up to 100 kilograms.
H5 degree of hardness has a perceived hardness classified as ultra-firm and is recommended for weight class of up to 120 kilograms. A rule of thumb is the younger, the firmer, and the older, the softer, but of course, personal preference also plays a role. The models in medium firmness like the Amerisleep Organica Mattress are usually the most adaptive for all types of sleepers.
All Tempur mattresses come with a 10–15-year guarantee, and many other manufacturers of similar mattresses have followed suit, which we like. However, with such a guaranteed length, TEMPUR® is probably on average. Consider models such as the Nolah Evolution 15.
The free sleep trial guarantee is also an important criterion. Many brands, such as Awara with the Organic Luxury Hybrid Mattress, offer up to a year of sleep trials. The range is usually between 30 days to a year for brands that offer them. But we don’t recommend brands that wouldn’t offer a sleep trial.
Some of the extra features to consider include:
The point elasticity: If a mattress is point-elastic, it only yields where the body exerts pressure. The higher the point elasticity, the better the mattress will adapt to the body. If, on the other hand, it has a surface-elastic effect, the entire surface gives way when pressure is applied. The point elasticity is also dependent on the volume weight.
The lying areas: Nowadays, the majority of mattresses, especially foam mattresses, are divided into so-called lying areas, also called the hardness of body zones. Mattresses with seven zones, in particular, are now widespread on the market. This has to do with the fact that this classification fits around 90 percent of the adult population. A 7-zone mattress has the following division:
First zone: The head area is rather firm, as it requires stable support, which also protects the neck from being over-twisted.
Second Zone: The softest zone is in the shoulder area so that shoulders and shoulder blades sink in without counter-pressure and the muscles are relieved.
Third Zone: The zone in the lumbar area is a little firmer to keep this area of the body stable and to relieve the spine.
Fourth Zone: In the hip or pelvic area, the zone is medium-firm so that the hips can sink in well and, together with the shoulder area, enable a straight spine.
Fifth zone: Like the third zone, the leg area is also sprung harder so that the legs and torso remain in a stable position.
Sixth Zone: Like Zone 2, the calf area is soft and ensures excellent blood circulation.
Seventh Zone: The foot zone is comparable to the head area and consists of a medium-strength material that supports the foot and takes the pressure off the joints, ankles, and heels.
To prevent soiling of the mattress cover and the penetration of sweat and dust into the mattress, it is strongly recommended to use a cover with a pro. Users should wash every two weeks at least 50 degrees Celsius.
With a rating of 9.9/10, the WinkBed is our Editor’s Choice. The mattress is designed for those who want pressure relief. The top layers are foam layers. Starting with a hyper soft foam up top helps with pressure relief. It is, therefore, our option of the best Tempurpedic alternative.
The Amerisleep Organica Mattress wins our Best Value pick. The Organica mattress is between a medium and a medium-firm on our scale. This means it’s going to be generally accommodating for all sleeper types: back, stomach, side, and combination sleepers. It has a rating of 9.7.
Rated 9.6/10, the Nolah Evolution 15 is our Best Hybrid Mattress. It has a combination of foam and coils and consists of a proprietary foam called the AirFoamICE™.